16 Recipes For Your Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner Menu (2024)

Thanksgiving is the greatest eating day of the year, hands down. It's all about cooking, eating, sharing, and enjoying, as well as reminiscing on family memories and recipes, and savoring some tastes we only get once a year.

This year, make your feast extra memorable by sprucing up a classic course or two with a new dish or technique that's destined to become a Thanksgiving staple at your annual turkey day feast. Here's what to cook if you're looking to serve a traditional Thanksgiving dinner with a modern twist.

20 Easy Thanksgiving Appetizers That Are Bound to Impress Your Guests

Turkey Pumpkin Chili

Kick off your feast with some of fall's greatest flavors, and a nice preview of the turkey-based feast to come. This healthy chili can be served in ramekins or even homemade bread bowls (hollow out a sourdough roll) to keep portions on the smaller side and stomachs ready for the main feast.

Brussels Sprouts Salad

Salad is certainly an important component of a Thanksgiving feast, even if prior generations didn't consider it essential. This shredded Brussels salad melds the flavors of Thanksgiving with a tangy dressing, plus sharp cheese for a well-balanced dish.

Sweet Potato and Brie Flatbread

This flatbread is quick to make and even faster to disappear off your table. The sweetness of the potatoes and soft cheese meld together so well, and can be topped with chili flakes for a little kick.

Butternut Squash Soup With Sage

This creamy soup can be prepped in advance, and served out of a slow cooker to keep it warm as guests trickle in. Use mugs, shot glasses, or soup bowls to serve this course.

Curried Cauliflower Soup

Add a little spice to your first course with this crowd-pleasing soup. Garnish with fresh herbs for a pop of color.

Main Course

A traditional main course on Thanksgiving is turkey, and plenty of it. Take a look at the different preparations below and decide which one works best for you.

Smoky Maple Turkey

Add a bit of smokiness and sweetness to your traditional Thanksgiving turkey. This recipe lets you cook the turkey in advance for a stress-free Thanksgiving Day, and then reheat it on lettuce to keep all the meat moist.

Roast Turkey Legs

If you're part of a dark meat-loving group, skip the whole bird and go straight for the drumsticks. Cooking only the legs saves time, money and the stress of carving. Plus, you can eat with your hands!

RELATED: 5 Clever Hacks for Cooking a Better Turkey

Smoked Turkey

Save room in the oven by resorting to an outdoor smoker to cook your Thanksgiving bird. This spatchco*cking and dry rub technique can also work for grilled turkey, and can save so much kitchen space.

Sides

For many, including those who don't eat meat or can't stand turkey, the sides are the real stars of a traditional Thanksgiving feast. We've included all the classics, such as mashed potatoes, stuffing, and more.

Make-Ahead Mashed Potatoes

Ensure the consistency of your mashed potatoes is just as creamy as you've fantasized about all year by making them a day ahead of time. Re-warming them with warm half-and-half gets the creaminess perfect and makes Thanksgiving Day a bit easier.

Sourdough and Sage Stuffing

Sourdough is the perfect stuffing bread because its crust stays nice and crisp, and the inner pieces get gooier and absorb flavor. This recipe is also easy to customize with suggested mix-ins, like bacon and pecans or pine nuts and raisins.

Green Beans With Bacon Vinaigrette

Switch up the classic casserole with this traditional-feeling green bean recipe that adds a welcome bacon-y twist. A house that smells like Thanksgiving plus bacon is a very nice place to be.

Honey-Butter Creamed Corn

Honey brings out corn's natural sweetness, and feels extra decadent in this creamy, buttery side dish. Frozen corn is a great shortcut here!

Bourbon Cranberry Compote

Elevate classic canned cranberry sauce with this easy-to-make cranberry compote that feels very sophisticated. It's great cold or at room temperature, and is also delicious on its own.

Desserts

No holiday meal is complete without dessert, especially not Thanksgiving dinner. Go with a classic, like pumpkin pie, or switch things up a bit with an apropos cake. It's your choice!

Cranberry Ricotta Cake

Go for a creamier, tarter dessert that will round out an excellent meal. This cake is light and buttery, and goes well with ice cream or even a scoop of Greek yogurt the next morning.

Pumpkin Pie

Fresh pumpkin pie is always a good idea. No can required, truly! Prepare to impress.

Sweet Potato Pie

Brown sugar, honey, and orange juice add just the right amount of depth and sweetness to this traditional Thanksgiving pie. Pre-made pie crust is also a totally acceptable shortcut here.